Insights · Comparison
Excel and Capital Refinery: what each does
Excel is the modeling canvas most private equity teams already use. Capital Refinery sits above it, turning the diligence pack into a memo with cited evidence instead of a file only its last editor can explain.
Excel is the universal modeling tool: flexible, transparent and instantly editable, and the tool most private equity professionals already model in. Capital Refinery does not replace Excel. It reads the diligence documents a deal team already has, spreads the figures with citations back to the source documents, and assembles the IC memo from that evidence, so the basis for approval does not depend on who last edited the model.
What Excel is built for
Excel is the universal modeling and analytical canvas. Private equity professionals model in it: formula transparency, instant iteration and no vendor lock-in. There is no replacing the modeling canvas, and no team seriously proposes trying.
For building a deal model from scratch, testing a scenario, or adjusting an assumption on the fly, Excel remains the tool of record, and that is not something Capital Refinery changes.
What Excel is built for
- Financial modeling and analytical iteration
- Formula transparency and instant iteration
- A universal canvas with no vendor lock-in
What Capital Refinery is built for
- Reading the diligence pack the team already has
- Spreading the figures with citations back to source
- Assembling the IC memo from that cited evidence
Where Excel stops
The model is the person who last edited it. Definitions drift between deals, external references break, and assumptions get copied forward from prior transactions without anyone re-checking them.
The memo summary ends up in a slide deck, the model stays in Excel, and months later nobody on the team can reconstruct the basis for the committee's approval. A polished spreadsheet can make incomplete diligence look complete.
Excel keeps its job as the modeling canvas. It was not built to be the record of what the committee decided and why.
How Capital Refinery works alongside Excel
Capital Refinery reads the income statement, balance sheet, cash flow, bank statements, QoE add-back schedule, credit agreement and compliance certificate, and spreads the figures with citations back to the source documents. It reads XLSX workbooks alongside PDFs.
Ten advisory reconciliation checks run on the spread and flag what doesn't tie, the team can accept, reject or negotiate each add-back, and five house stress scenarios (rate, income, collateral and combined) show the modeled downside before the committee votes. Memo sections are assembled from that cited evidence and export as DOCX with an evidence fingerprint.
The governed payload — reconciled, reviewed, current.
A crs_… content hash. Verifiable by anyone, no login.
A standard tab set. You map once with XLOOKUP; refresh forever.
Formulas untouched. Capital Refinery never maintains it.
The four accented columns are the part a plain spreadsheet export cannot reproduce — audit-grade provenance one XLOOKUP away from any assumption cell in your own model.
The snapshot id resolves and every value still reconciles to source. Refresh is a no-op.
The live deal state has moved. The workbook is readable but stale — pull a fresh snapshot before you rely on it.
An identity or attestation no longer resolves. The gate withholds the claim rather than guessing a number.

Excel and Capital Refinery at a glance
A side-by-side read of what each product does.
| Capability | Excel | Capital Refinery |
|---|---|---|
| Financial modeling and analytical iteration | Yes, universal canvas | Not the goal, Excel stays |
| Source-backed numbers (figures cite their source) | No, manual cell traces and external references that break | Yes, traced to source where a locator resolves |
| Risk signals graded against firm policy | No, manual reconciliation per deal | Yes, re-grades on the next render |
| Add-back review (accept, reject, negotiate) | Manual, per deal | Yes, per item in the EBITDA bridge |
| Structured memo assembled from evidence | Built from scratch each deal | Yes, same shape each deal |
| Drift tracked against the IC-approved case | Manual reconstruction quarter to quarter | Yes, since-IC drift against the approval anchor |
| Workbook file format support | Native | XLSX workbooks read alongside PDFs |
Questions
Is Capital Refinery an alternative to Excel?
No. Excel is the modeling canvas, and Capital Refinery does not replace it. Capital Refinery reads the diligence pack, spreads the figures to cited evidence, and assembles the memo the committee reviews.
Can I use Excel and Capital Refinery together?
Yes. The deal team keeps modeling in Excel, and Capital Refinery reads the diligence pack separately, spreading the figures with citations back to the source documents for the memo.
What does Excel not do?
Excel does not cite its own numbers to a source, run reconciliation checks automatically, or keep the basis for a committee's approval from depending on who last edited the file.
What is Excel used for in private equity underwriting?
Excel is the universal modeling tool private equity teams use to build the deal model, test assumptions and iterate on scenarios ahead of committee.
Does Capital Refinery replace my deal model?
No. Capital Refinery does not touch the model's formulas. It reads the diligence pack on the side and assembles the IC memo from cited evidence, independent of the model file.