Insights · Comparison
Macabacus and Capital Refinery: what each does
Macabacus makes the spreadsheet and the deck faster to build. Capital Refinery makes the memo that comes out of them defensible in front of the committee.
Macabacus is a productivity add-in for Excel and PowerPoint: formatting, formula auditing, model navigation and deck production for the analyst building the model. Capital Refinery is a different layer: it reads the diligence pack the deal team already has, spreads the financials to a standard structure with figures traced to source, and assembles memo sections from that cited evidence. Teams run both: Macabacus builds the model, Capital Refinery defends the memo that cites it.
What Macabacus is built for
Macabacus is the productivity layer for analysts who live in Excel and PowerPoint. It formats, audits formulas, navigates between model tabs and sheets, and speeds up deck production. For the mechanical work of building and checking a model, it is a strong, focused tool, and most teams that adopt it keep it for exactly that.
Macabacus is built for
- Excel and PowerPoint formatting and formula auditing
- Model navigation across tabs and workbooks
- Faster deck production for the IC pack
Capital Refinery is built for
- Reading the diligence pack and spreading figures traced to source
- Grading risk signals against the firm's own policy thresholds
- Assembling memo sections from cited evidence for the committee
- Cuts hours of mechanical formatting and auditing work for analysts
- Keeps model navigation consistent across a large workbook
- Right tool for the analyst productivity layer, not for the committee record
Where Macabacus stops
Macabacus speeds up the model. It does not read the underlying documents, cite a figure to the page it came from, or carry the committee's decision forward once the model is built. The spreadsheet gets faster to produce; what happens to the IC record after the meeting sits in a different layer of the stack.
The model gets faster. Whether the memo built on top of it survives the next committee question is a different layer.
How Capital Refinery works alongside Macabacus
Capital Refinery does not compete with Macabacus and does not touch the spreadsheet layer. It reads the documents and reports the deal team already has, and sits above the model as the record the committee actually reviews.
- Classifies each document on arrival against a 41-family taxonomy that covers the income statement, balance sheet, cash flow, bank statements, QoE add-back schedule, credit agreement and compliance certificate
- Spreads financial statements to a standard structure, with figures traced to the source document and cited to the page where a locator resolves
- Runs ten advisory reconciliation checks on the spread before analysis; they flag for review and never gate the run
- Lets the deal team accept, reject or negotiate each add-back in the EBITDA bridge
- Grades risk signals against the firm's own policy thresholds; move a threshold and the memo re-grades on the next render
- Assembles memo sections from that cited evidence, and records committee conditions as tracked actions on the deal
Macabacus and Capital Refinery at a glance
| Capability | Macabacus | Capital Refinery |
|---|---|---|
| Excel and PowerPoint productivity | Yes, core capability | No, does not touch the spreadsheet layer |
| Formula auditing and model navigation | Yes | No |
| Deck production for the IC pack | Yes | No, assembles memo sections instead |
| Reads diligence documents and cites figures to source | No | Yes, classified against a 41-family document taxonomy |
| Memo sections assembled from cited evidence | No, the memo is built by hand on top of the model | Yes |
| Risk signals graded to the firm's own policy | No | Yes, re-grades on the next render |
| Committee conditions tracked after close | No | Yes, recorded as tracked actions on the deal |
Questions
Is Capital Refinery an alternative to Macabacus?
Usually no. Macabacus is an Excel and PowerPoint productivity add-in for analysts building the model. Capital Refinery reads the diligence pack and assembles the memo that cites it. Most teams keep both; they do different jobs.
Can I use Macabacus and Capital Refinery together?
Yes. Macabacus speeds up the modeling and deck work an analyst does in Excel and PowerPoint. Capital Refinery reads the underlying documents, spreads the figures with citations, and assembles the memo the committee reviews.
What does Macabacus not do?
Macabacus does not read the source documents, cite a figure to the page it came from, grade risk against firm policy, or carry committee conditions forward after the deal closes. It is a modeling productivity tool, not a decision record.
Does Capital Refinery replace the Excel model?
No. The model stays where it is, and Macabacus still helps build it. Capital Refinery reads the documents behind the model and produces the cited memo that sits above it.
Who uses Macabacus and Capital Refinery together?
Analysts who already use Macabacus for modeling speed bring the same source pack to Capital Refinery so the committee's memo cites the underlying documents instead of resting on the model alone.