Insights · Blog

Most firms know what was decided. Far fewer know when it stopped being correct.

The difference between drift and a broken decision, and why most monitoring systems don't surface the second.

5 min readUpdated October 2026Capital Refinery research

The short answer

Drift means conditions changed. A broken decision means the committee's original call is no longer defensible given what those conditions are now. A decision breaks when a low-severity call, such as monitor or watch, is followed by conditions that cross a materiality threshold, such as critical covenant status or a refinance window inside six months, after the call was made. It clears only when the committee reconvenes and makes a new call.

The difference between drift and a broken decision

Drift means conditions changed. The world moved. A broken decision means the committee's call is no longer defensible given what those conditions are now. Drift is descriptive. A broken decision is prescriptive: the governance basis recorded no longer holds, and something has to change.

Drift

  • Conditions changed since the call
  • Descriptive: the world moved
  • Shows up as a number that moved

A broken decision

  • The committee's basis for the call no longer holds
  • Prescriptive: something has to change
  • Clears only when the committee reconvenes

Why most monitoring systems do not catch it

Most monitoring tools are built around metrics. They track what changed, alert on movement, and show updated numbers. They do not connect that movement to the decision that was made before it, which is the only way a system can say a decision is no longer correct.

That requires storing two things together that most systems keep apart: the committee's call, and the current signal state. Only when those two are connected can a system say what most tools don't say: the decision is no longer correct.

What materiality means here

The committee made a low-severity call: monitor, stable, continue, watch. Conditions have since moved to a materially worse state. Breach pressure is present, covenant status has deteriorated to critical, or the refinance window has compressed to six months or fewer.

The original decision

What the committee called it, when, and on what basis.

The moment it stopped holding

The date conditions crossed the materiality threshold.

The exposure duration

How long the position has run on a decision that is no longer correct.

What to do now

A specific recommendation, not a note to re-evaluate.

What Capital Refinery reads to show this

Capital Refinery reads each reporting pack the team already receives to its covenant terms, traces the figures to their source, and grades the resulting risk signals against the firm's own thresholds. A change to a threshold re-grades the memo on its next render.

Covenant monitoring screen: screen coming soon
Live product screen · illustrative data

The clear condition

A broken decision does not clear when metrics improve. It clears when the committee reconvenes and makes a new call: the record, the materiality event, and the counter-decision, in sequence, with timestamps.

Bring five positions. See which decisions are no longer correct, the moment each one crossed the threshold, and what the committee has to reconvene on.

Questions

What is the difference between decision drift and a broken decision?

Drift means conditions changed; it is descriptive. A broken decision means the committee's original call is no longer defensible given the current conditions; it is prescriptive, and something has to change.

When does a decision count as broken rather than just drifted?

When a low-severity call, such as monitor or watch, is followed by conditions that cross a materiality threshold, such as critical covenant status or a refinance window inside six months, after the call was made.

Why don't most monitoring dashboards catch a broken decision?

They track what changed and alert on movement, but they store the committee's call and the current signal state separately, so they don't connect the two or ask what the movement does to the decision.

When does a broken decision clear?

Only when the committee reconvenes and makes a new call. Improving metrics alone do not clear it; the record needs the materiality event and the counter-decision, in sequence, with timestamps.

Accelerate your deal execution process.

Private markets, connected. Bring automation to your deal execution.

Founder-led access. Every working session runs on your actual documents, not a generic demo.