Insights · Guide
One investment decision, from committee approval through LP verification
Most product pages describe what they do. This one walks a single investment decision through Capital Refinery stage by stage, from committee approval to the exported record a limited partner can later review.
A Capital Refinery decision moves through five stages: committee approval, where conditions are recorded; close, where conditions set from the approved baseline begin to be evaluated against actuals; ongoing monitoring, where each new compliance certificate and registered deliverable is tested against its covenant and risk signals grade against firm policy; stress testing, where five fixed house scenarios run before the next decision; and export, where the memo leaves the platform with its sources and provenance attached.
One decision, five stages
A platform's feature list is not the same thing as what happens to one decision after the committee votes. Below is one decision, followed stage by stage, through what Capital Refinery actually does at each point, approval, close, ongoing monitoring, stress testing, and the eventual export. The order is fixed. Each stage produces a specific, reproducible artifact.
Committee approval
The committee votes. The recommendation, the conditions attached to it, and the add-back positions behind the EBITDA bridge are recorded as the team approved them.
Close
The conditions the committee attached to its approval become monitored conditions on the position, not a line in an approval email.
Monitoring
Each new compliance certificate and registered deliverable is tested against its covenant. Headroom and drift show against the thresholds the committee set, with figures traced to source and cited where a locator resolves.
Stress testing
Five fixed house stress scenarios run, rate, income and collateral shocks, with the first-breach quarter modeled, so the team sees the downside before the next decision has to be made, not after.
Export
The memo leaves the platform as a DOCX with its evidence fingerprint, for the next committee meeting, the auditor, or the limited partner.
Each stage renders from the same cited evidence. The memo the committee saw at approval and the memo exported eighteen months later are built from the same documents, not two separate reconstructions.
Why decision quality and decision outcome are not the same question
A good decision under uncertainty can still produce a bad outcome. A bad decision can still produce a good one. Writers on decision-making under uncertainty, Annie Duke, Michael Mauboussin, Daniel Kahneman, Philip Tetlock, Atul Gawande, treat that separation as the starting point, not a caveat. The practical question for a deal team is not whether the outcome was good. It is whether the record shows what the team knew, what it tested, and what it approved, at the moment it approved it.
That record is what the stages above build. The add-back record shows which positions were accepted, rejected or negotiated. The stress pack shows the downside the committee saw before it voted. The exported memo keeps the citations attached, so a reader eighteen months later is reading the same evidence the committee read, not a reconstruction built from memory.
- Annie Duke, Thinking in Bets (2018)
- Michael Mauboussin, The Success Equation (2012)
- Daniel Kahneman, with Olivier Sibony and Cass Sunstein, Noise (2021)
- Philip Tetlock, with Dan Gardner, Superforecasting (2015)
- Atul Gawande, The Checklist Manifesto (2009)
- ILPA Principles, Institutional Limited Partners Association governance and reporting standards
What this is arguing, structurally
What this is arguing, structurally, is four things, each one a property of the stages above rather than a feature on its own.
- Decisions do not have to drift silently. Each reporting pack is read to the thresholds the committee set, and the gap shows as a graded risk signal, not a surprise at the next meeting.
- Decisions do not have to disappear into notes. The conditions recorded at approval stay attached to the position as monitored conditions, through close and beyond.
- Decision quality stays decoupled from decision outcome. The exported memo documents what the team tested and approved at the moment of commitment, whatever the position does afterward.
- Output inherits the same evidence. The memo at approval, the stress pack at month nine, and the export at month eighteen all render from the same cited documents, with no manual rebuild between them.
What this kills, in operational terms
The failure mode this replaces is not a bad decision. It is a decision whose basis cannot be reconstructed later, by the team that made it or by the limited partner asking about it. What this kills, in operational terms, is the email chain that stands in for a record, and the memo that has to be rebuilt from a spreadsheet someone can no longer find. A structured record does not make the judgment for the committee. It keeps what the committee already decided attached to the position instead of letting it drift into separate systems, inboxes, slide decks, a hard drive that left with the analyst who built the model.
Before: the record lives in inboxes
- Where did we land on this, answered by searching an email thread
- A memo rebuilt from a spreadsheet someone can no longer find
- What did we know at the time, answered by whoever remembers best
After: the record stays attached to the position
- Conditions recorded at approval become monitored conditions at close
- The memo renders from the same cited evidence each time, not a fresh draft
- An exported memo carries the evidence that supported it, for the next reader
Capital Refinery's part in each stage
Capital Refinery does not make the call. It reads the documents the deal team already has and keeps the record attached to the position as it moves through the stages above.
- Classifies documents across 41 families on arrival, including the income statement, balance sheet, cash flow, bank statements, the QoE add-back schedule, the credit agreement, and the compliance certificate, with figures traced to source and cited where a locator resolves.
- Runs 10 advisory reconciliation checks on the spread; they flag inconsistencies and never block the analysis.
- Records a buyer position on each add-back: accepted, rejected or negotiated.
- Runs five fixed house stress scenarios before the committee has to decide again.
- Grades risk signals against the firm's own policy thresholds; move a threshold and the memo re-grades on its next render.
- Assembles memo sections from that cited evidence; the narrative sections stay with the deal team.
- Records committee conditions that become monitored conditions once the position closes.
- Exports the memo as DOCX with its evidence fingerprint.

The same read, from the lender's or the seller's seat
The stages above trace a buy-side approval. The same underlying read also supports a lender's covenant monitoring on the credit side of a position, and a seller-side readiness review before a company goes to market. Different audience, same documents, same citation discipline.
A lender reading the same credit agreement and compliance certificate sees the covenant headroom and the drift against the threshold it set at close, not a borrower's narrative summary of its own compliance. A seller preparing for a process sees the same gaps in documentation and governance that a buyer's diligence team would otherwise surface for the first time, weeks into the process. Neither reader gets a different record. They get the same citation trail, read for their own question.
Run this on a position you hold
Bring a position, a deal you are underwriting, a deal you closed last quarter, a portfolio company under watch, and see the artifact at each stage above, built from your own documents.
The judgment stays the committee's. What changes is whether the basis for the call is still there to read, eighteen months later, in full, with the citations attached.
Questions
What happens to an investment decision after the IC approves it?
The conditions the committee attached to its approval become monitored conditions once the position closes. Each certificate and registered deliverable is tested against its covenant, and risk signals grade against the firm's own policy thresholds as new data arrives.
Does Capital Refinery replace the investment committee?
No. The committee makes the call. Capital Refinery assembles the memo from cited evidence, tracks the conditions the committee attached, and keeps that record attached to the position.
What is the difference between decision quality and decision outcome?
Decision quality is whether the call was sound given what the team knew and tested at the time. Decision outcome is how the position actually performed. A good decision can still have a bad outcome, and the reverse is also true.
Can the exported memo show what the committee knew when it approved the deal?
The exported memo keeps the cited evidence that supported the approval, and conditions set from the approved baseline stay attached to the position and are re-evaluated as actuals arrive. It is the documented record, not a transcript of the discussion.
Is Falcon, the deal shown in the product screens, a real customer?
No. Falcon is the real-shaped fixture used across Capital Refinery's product screens to illustrate the workflow. Capital Refinery does not yet have named customer examples to publish.