Insights · Learn

How an LP's IC actually evaluates a fund (vs how they should)

LP investment committees ask one question well and several others poorly. Here is the gap between the questions LPs actually ask and the questions a structurally sound review would ask.

8 min readUpdated October 2026Capital Refinery research

The short answer

LP investment committees reliably ask one question well: how the fund performs against its vintage benchmark. They ask several other questions poorly or not at all: whether the GP's decisions were good decisions or lucky outcomes, whether governance documentation would survive independent review, and whether the GP's process stays consistent across the portfolio. Sophisticated LPs are closing that gap by demanding structured decision evidence instead of narrative quarterly letters.

3questions LPs ask well, out of eight that matter
8questions a structurally sound LP review covers, by this framework
2024year the SEC's Private Fund Adviser Rules were vacated by the 5th Circuit

Why this matters across two audiences

The gap between actual LP review and a structurally sound LP review is the gap between what GPs prepare for and what GPs should prepare for.

  • GPs preparing for LP review: see what LPs typically ask versus what sophisticated LPs increasingly ask, and prepare for both. The gap is closing as LPs professionalize diligence under the ILPA Principles.
  • LPs evaluating GPs: see the structural gap between common LP IC practice and what evidence-based fund evaluation actually requires.

The setting: what an LP IC meeting actually looks like

A sophisticated institutional LP, a public pension, an endowment, a sovereign wealth fund or a large family office, convenes its investment committee to evaluate a fund commitment or a re-up. The committee has typically reviewed the GP's pitch book, a quarterly report set, an audited fund financial statement, references from existing LPs and, when commissioned, a third-party investment-consultant evaluation. The discussion runs thirty to sixty minutes; the chair frames the decision and the staff recommendation is voted up or down.

Cambridge Associates documents wide performance dispersion across private fund vintages. The dispersion implies that LP allocation choice, not just access, meaningfully drives returns.

The LPs that consistently land top-quartile allocations are doing diligence most LP investment committees are not: they are asking the second set of questions below, not just the first.

The questions LPs actually ask, and ask well

Three questions get asked consistently and answered well.

01

Performance vs vintage benchmark

Cambridge Associates, Preqin, PitchBook and ILPA all publish vintage-year benchmarks. Most LP ICs ask where the fund sits against it, and the answer is verifiable and comparable.

02

Team continuity and key-person risk

Whether the team that produced historical performance is the team that will produce future performance, and whether key-person provisions exist in the partnership agreement.

03

Strategy consistency

Whether the GP is doing what it said it would do: the same target deal size, sector focus and geography. This question is asked consistently but often answered informally.

The questions LPs should ask, and often do not

Five questions get asked rarely, informally, or not at all, and they are the ones that would most change the committee's conviction.

QuestionWhat it actually tests
Decision quality vs decision outcomeWhether an underperforming position was underwritten well and ran into a difficult outcome, or underwritten poorly. Most LP ICs see the outcome but not the decision basis.
Governance documentationWhether the GP has a documented conflict-of-interest and related-party policy that can survive independent review, not just a verbal representation.
Process discipline across the portfolioWhether the GP applies the same IC framework consistently across deals, or whether approval criteria drift over the fund's life.
Portfolio-level risk signals against firm policyWhether the GP's portfolio renders against the LP's own policy thresholds in a form the LP can verify, rather than something the LP has to rebuild from quarterly data.
Audit-defensibility of the decision recordWhether the LP could answer a board or regulator's question about a soured investment with structured evidence, rather than its memory of what the GP said.

Why the gap exists

The gap is not laziness. Three structural reasons drive it: information asymmetry, since the GP knows the decision basis and the LP knows only the outcome; LP staffing, since most LP investment teams cover many GP commitments with little capacity for evidence-based review on each position; and historical norms, since for most of private capital's history LP review was performance-and-team-driven, because that was what was knowable from the available reporting.

How sophisticated LPs are closing the gap

  • Demanding ILPA-aligned reporting templates with documented KPI definitions and a consistent quarterly cadence, moving away from narrative letters toward structured data.
  • Requiring audit-grade fund financials, and in some cases portfolio-company financials at reviewed or audited grade.
  • Asking explicitly for the GP's decision framework: typed decisions, downside scenarios named at the IC, forward indicators committed before approval.
  • Verifying GP claims independently, including valuation reviews on sponsor marks and cross-checks of claimed strategy consistency against deal-level data.
  • Treating the GP's decision-record infrastructure as diligence-relevant in its own right, separate from trailing performance.

For GPs preparing for review, the practical implication is to prepare for both sets of questions, not just the well-asked set, and to treat decision-record discipline as a fundraising asset rather than only an operating discipline. For LPs evaluating GPs, performance benchmarking is necessary but not sufficient: the wide vintage dispersion Cambridge Associates documents means a top-quartile outcome can come from a top-quartile process or a fortunate run through a weaker one, and the performance number alone does not say which.

Sources cited

  1. ILPA Principles: Institutional Limited Partners Association governance and reporting standards.
  2. Cambridge Associates Private Investment Benchmarks: fund performance dispersion data.
  3. Bain Global Private Equity Report (annual): process-discipline patterns across top- and bottom-quartile firms.
  4. Preqin and PitchBook: private fund vintage benchmark data.
  5. SEC Private Fund Adviser Rules (2023 final rule, vacated by the 5th Circuit in 2024): not in force, but a useful reference for institutional LP governance expectations alongside the ILPA Principles.

What this implies for the record a GP keeps

Capital Refinery's monitoring reads each reporting pack to its terms, with headroom and drift shown since approval, and grades risk signals against the firm's own policy thresholds rather than a generic benchmark. Open conditions and covenant obligations stay on the same deal record, so the record an LP would ask to see and the record the GP already keeps can be the same record.

The LP review practice that was sufficient in 2010 is not sufficient now. A GP that can produce a sourced decision record is answering a question most LP ICs have only started asking.

Portfolio monitoring screen
Live product screen · illustrative data

Questions

What question do LP investment committees ask well?

Performance against the vintage benchmark. Cambridge Associates, Preqin, PitchBook and ILPA all publish the comparison data, so the answer is verifiable and comparable.

What questions do LP investment committees often skip?

Decision quality versus decision outcome, governance documentation that can survive independent review, process discipline across the portfolio, portfolio-level risk signals against the LP's own policy, and audit-defensibility of the decision record.

Why is decision quality different from decision outcome?

A position can underperform after being underwritten well, or outperform after being underwritten poorly. Most LP investment committees see only the outcome, not the decision basis that produced it.

What happened to the SEC's Private Fund Adviser Rules?

The SEC finalized the rules in 2023; the 5th Circuit vacated them in 2024. They are not in force, though the underlying expectations, quarterly statements, audits, related-party disclosure, remain a useful reference alongside the ILPA Principles.

How are sophisticated LPs closing the diligence gap?

By demanding ILPA-aligned structured reporting instead of narrative letters, requiring audit-grade financials, asking for the GP's decision framework explicitly, and verifying GP claims independently rather than accepting them at face value.

Accelerate your deal execution process.

Private markets, connected. Bring automation to your deal execution.

Founder-led access. Every working session runs on your actual documents, not a generic demo.