Insights · Guide
Can you defend the mark? Valuation defensibility
Valuation support that survives the next question. Capital Refinery ties the support for a mark back to source evidence, operating drift, and covenant posture, so the trail is already there when the LP, auditor, or regulator asks.
A fair-value mark gets challenged, by the LP that secondaries-shopped it, by the auditor on the annual cycle, by the regulator after a complaint. The defense is not the mark itself. It is the trail underneath it: the source documents behind the underwrite, the KPI figures traced to source, and what has moved since the committee approved. Capital Refinery reads those documents and assembles the memo from the cited evidence, so the trail exists before the question is asked.
The mark is reported. The basis behind it has drifted.
Carrying a position at fair value is no longer only an internal accounting choice. It is a number that gets challenged, by the LP that secondaries-shopped the stake, by the auditor on the annual cycle, by the regulator following a complaint. The challenge lands on the person whose name is on the deal, not the firm in aggregate.
The defense is not the mark. The defense is the trail underneath it: the source documents that supported the underwrite, the KPI figures that justified the assumptions, the covenant posture that justified the discount rate, and the record of what the team actually approved and when. Most firms cannot reconstruct that trail quickly. The room searches folders instead.
A valuation that cannot be defended on the trail underneath it is a number waiting for the next question.
Valuation pressure is no longer a quarterly footnote
| Source | Finding |
|---|---|
| Mercer Capital (2026) | If an asset cannot be readily sold at NAV, then NAV is not fair value; persistent discounts suggest private BDC NAVs are too high relative to public pricing signals. |
| Skadden, Arps (2025) | The FCA expects firms to identify, document, and assess valuation-related conflicts; only a few firms clearly demonstrated functional independence in their valuation process. |
| Debevoise & Plimpton (2025) | The US Attorney for SDNY signaled increased prosecutorial interest in whether private fund advisers value portfolio assets in ways that increase fees to investors. |
| Jefferies, Global Secondary Market Review (2025) | Average LP-portfolio pricing reached about 90% of NAV in H1 2025; transaction-weighted average discounts were 13.3%, with buyout portfolios trading at roughly 11.6% and credit secondaries at about 92% of NAV. |
| CFA Institute, Enterprising Investor (2026) | Private credit lacks an independent process for verifying the numbers underlying complex transactions; Level 3 valuations carry the greatest potential for error and the most scrutiny. |
Three rooms where defend the mark gets asked out loud
The LP secondaries call
Your stake is being shopped at a discount to NAV. What changed? The defensible answer shows the underwrite, what has moved against it since, and what the team did about it.
The audit cycle
Walk us through the basis for this Level 3 mark. Auditors want the methodology, the inputs, the comparables, and the trail back to source documents, not a rebuild from email and slide decks.
The quarterly mark review
Has anything that supported this mark drifted since the committee approved it? Most firms cannot answer cleanly because the approval record and the current operating data live in different systems.
Reconstructing the trail, before and after
Rebuilding the trail under pressure
- The team searches email and slide decks to reconstruct what supported the mark
- KPI figures get re-keyed from memory into a new support deck for the auditor
- Whether anything has drifted since approval depends on who remembers the original memo
The trail already assembled
- Figures in the support package are traced to source, cited to the page where a locator resolves
- The memo sections render from the same cited evidence approved at the committee stage
- Committee conditions recorded at approval are tracked as monitored conditions through the hold
What goes into the valuation support package
Capital Refinery does not generate the mark. It reads the documents behind the position and assembles the support underneath it, using the same primitives that run the rest of the platform.
- Classifies documents across 41 families on arrival, including the income statement, balance sheet, cash flow, bank statements, the QoE add-back schedule, the credit agreement, and the compliance certificate, with figures traced to source and cited where a locator resolves.
- Runs 10 advisory reconciliation checks on the spread, so figures underneath the mark that do not tie out are flagged; the checks flag and never block.
- Records a buyer position on each add-back behind the underwrite: accepted, rejected or negotiated.
- Reads each new reporting pack and compliance certificate to its terms, with headroom and drift traced to the document.
- Grades risk signals against the firm's own policy thresholds; move a threshold and the memo re-grades on its next render.
- Assembles memo sections from that cited evidence; the narrative sections stay with the deal team.
- Records committee conditions that become monitored conditions once the position closes.
- Exports the memo as DOCX with its evidence fingerprint, for the auditor or the LP.

Pressure-test one valuation support package
Send one mark the team might personally have to defend in the next 90 days. Capital Refinery returns the support package, the source documents, the add-back positions, and the covenant posture, built for the partner who owns it.
Questions
What makes a fair-value mark defensible?
A trail back to source documents: the underwrite, the KPI figures traced to their source, the covenant posture, and a record of what the committee approved and when, assembled before the question is asked rather than after.
Does Capital Refinery generate the valuation mark itself?
No. It reads the documents behind the position and assembles the support package underneath the mark. The mark itself remains the team's determination.
Why are LPs pricing secondaries stakes below reported NAV?
Jefferies reported average LP-portfolio pricing at about 90% of NAV in H1 2025, with transaction-weighted discounts around 13.3%, suggesting the market's view of fair value runs below many GP marks.
What do auditors want to see for a Level 3 mark?
The methodology, the inputs, the comparables, and a trail back to source documents, rather than a support deck rebuilt from email and slide decks after the fact.
How does Capital Refinery show what has changed since the committee approved a position?
Each new compliance certificate and registered deliverable is tested against its covenant, with headroom and drift traced to the document, so the current position can be compared against the terms the committee approved.