Insights · Comparison
Why generic AI tools fail in private markets, and what Capital Refinery does instead
A chat assistant can summarize a document in seconds. It cannot cite a figure to its source page, flag a conflict instead of guessing, or hold a committee's decision as a record. See where generic AI tools stop, and what Capital Refinery does once the output has to survive the room.
Generic AI tools are chat assistants: they summarize documents, draft text, and answer questions, but they do not trace figures to their source or hold a decision as a structured record. Capital Refinery reads diligence documents, spreads figures to cited evidence, grades risk signals against firm policy, and assembles memo sections from that evidence. Teams use a chat assistant for research and Capital Refinery for the parts of the workflow that have to survive an IC review.
What generic AI tools are built for
Generic AI tools are chat assistants built on large language models. Point one at a document and it will summarize it, answer a question about it, or draft text from it. For research, first drafts, and brainstorming, that is fast and genuinely useful.
The failure shows up only once the output has to survive a room: an IC memo that holds up under scrutiny, figures that trace to a source cell, a decision that stays defensible after the deal closes.
Where generic AI tools stop
A chat window does not enforce a schema, so the same metric can carry a different definition in two conversations with the same tool. It does not carry provenance, so a supported answer and an unsupported one read identically confident. And it does not label which numbers in its own output were read from a document versus generated.
| Failure mode | Why it happens | What Capital Refinery does instead |
|---|---|---|
| Inconsistent figures across the same deal | A chat tool does not enforce a schema or a mapping rule between conversations | Reads figures from the source document and traces them to source, cited to the page where a locator resolves |
| Unsupported claims that read confident | A language model generates text; it does not carry provenance for a figure | Memo figures trace back to the document they were read from |
| Ambiguity answered instead of flagged | A locked file or a conflict between two documents gets a guessed answer instead of a refusal | Locked files and conflicting documents become a review item a person resolves |
| No record of what changed since approval | Each memo is a one-off rewrite, not a structured record | Committee conditions are recorded as tracked actions attached to the decision |
How Capital Refinery works alongside generic AI tools
Capital Refinery is not a chat window. It classifies each document on arrival against a 41-family taxonomy that covers the income statement, balance sheet, cash flow, bank statements, QoE add-back schedule, credit agreement, and compliance certificate, and spreads figures to a standard structure, traced to source and cited to the page where a locator resolves.
- Runs ten advisory reconciliation checks on the spread before analysis; they flag for review and never gate the run.
- Lets the deal team accept, reject, or negotiate each add-back in the EBITDA bridge.
- Runs five house stress scenarios (rate, NOI, collateral and combined shocks) so the committee sees a modeled downside before it votes.
- Grades risk signals against the firm's own policy thresholds; move a threshold and the memo re-grades on the next render.
- Assembles memo sections from that cited evidence; the narrative sections stay with the deal team.
- Uses a large language model only to choose among deterministic extraction candidates. It does not generate figures from scratch.

Generic AI tools and Capital Refinery at a glance
A side-by-side read of where each stops.
| Capability | Generic AI tools | Capital Refinery |
|---|---|---|
| Summarize and draft from a document | Yes, core capability | Not the goal; reads the document to cited figures instead |
| Trace figures to their source | No, not by default | Yes, figures traced to source; cited to the page where a locator resolves |
| Flag ambiguity instead of guessing | No, a confident answer is produced either way | Yes, locked files and document conflicts become a human review item |
| Label which figures a model touched | No | Yes, extraction candidates are adjudicated, not generated from scratch |
| Hold committee conditions as tracked actions | No | Yes, recorded as tracked actions on the deal |
What to require of any AI in your workflow
These are not prompt-engineering problems. They are structural problems with treating private markets work as ask-and-answer instead of as a governed lifecycle: underwriting, IC, portfolio, exit.
- Figures should click back to the source document, not to a generated paragraph.
- Each export should carry evidence a reviewer, not just the tool, can check.
- Each committee approval should anchor to a record that renders the same figures later.
- Each operator update should be checked against the original underwriting, not treated as a fresh question.
Bring a real deal pack, not a demo
The fastest way to see the difference is to bring a CIM, a credit agreement, or a financial model Capital Refinery has not seen. The diagnostic pack comes back source-backed and graded against the firm's own policy, not a demo data set.
A chat assistant speeds up the draft. It does not carry the citation the committee needs to defend it two quarters later.
Questions
Is Capital Refinery an alternative to generic AI tools?
Mostly no. Generic AI tools are chat assistants for research, drafting, and summarizing. Capital Refinery reads diligence documents, traces figures to their source, and assembles the IC memo from that evidence. Teams often use a chat tool for early research and Capital Refinery for the parts of the workflow that have to hold up at committee.
Can I use a generic AI tool and Capital Refinery together?
Yes. A chat assistant is useful for drafting and early research. Capital Refinery takes over once the output has to cite a source, survive a committee vote, or stay attached to a decision after close.
What does a generic AI tool not do?
It does not enforce a consistent schema across a deal, does not cite each figure to a source page by default, and does not flag a locked file or a document conflict instead of guessing at an answer.
Why can't I just prompt a chat tool to cite its sources?
A prompt can ask for citations, but the tool still generates the surrounding text and cannot guarantee the number it reports was read rather than produced. Capital Refinery's extraction is deterministic first; a model only adjudicates among candidates already extracted from the document.
What happens when a document is locked or two documents disagree?
Capital Refinery does not guess. A locked file or a conflict between two documents becomes a review item that a person on the deal team resolves.