Insights · Comparison

Quality of earnings and Capital Refinery: what each does

A quality of earnings report is the institutional standard for transaction-time financial validation: rigorous, expensive, and scoped to a specific mandate. Capital Refinery reads the same kind of evidence months earlier and across a wider set of readiness axes.

9 min readUpdated October 2026Capital Refinery research

The short answer

A quality of earnings report from a credible provider reconstructs adjusted EBITDA, tests working capital, and surfaces accounting policy risk, scoped to a transaction window. Capital Refinery reads the same financials and the QoE add-back schedule, runs ten advisory reconciliation checks, and grades the result across ten readiness axes with a public verification link. Teams typically run Capital Refinery first, then commission the quality of earnings report on a cleaner evidence trail.

10advisory reconciliation checks that flag, never gate
5house stress scenarios modeled per deal
10axes graded in the readiness assessment

What quality of earnings is built for

A quality of earnings report from a credible provider, such as the Big 4 transaction services teams or a respected boutique, is the gold standard for one specific question: do the financial statements in front of the deal team reflect the actual earning power of the business? Capital Refinery does not try to replace that work.

A good report reconstructs adjusted EBITDA by normalizing for one-time items, owner perks, accounting policy choices and run-rate adjustments, the line buyers actually pay against. It tests the working capital cycle, validating the receivables, payables and inventory shape against the statements and identifying the working capital peg. It surfaces accounting policy risk such as revenue recognition timing, expense capitalization and contingent liabilities, and it carries institutional credibility: a well-known name on the cover materially shifts how a buyer's committee reads the numbers.

What a quality of earnings report is built for

  • Reconstructing adjusted EBITDA with normalization adjustments
  • Testing the working capital cycle and the peg
  • Surfacing accounting policy risk
  • Carrying the issuing firm's institutional credibility

What Capital Refinery is built for

  • Reading the financials and the QoE add-back schedule with figures traced to source
  • Running ten advisory reconciliation checks before analysis
  • Letting the team accept, reject or negotiate each add-back
  • Grading readiness across ten axes with a public verification link

Where quality of earnings stops

A quality of earnings report answers one question well, and it runs late. It is commissioned inside a transaction window, usually after a term sheet or letter of intent, so the conflicts and gaps it surfaces are surfaced under deal pressure, with a clock running, and they can re-price or kill the deal.

  • It scopes mainly to the financial statements: adjusted EBITDA, working capital and accounting policy, not governance, customer concentration or key-person dependency.
  • It produces a bound report with no public verification link or fingerprint a downstream lender or board can check independently.
  • It is not reproducible by a third party: re-running it means hiring another firm to write another report.
  • It does not surface what is blocking a broader readiness view, such as reporting cadence or customer concentration, even though any of those can still kill a deal if surfaced at the wrong moment.

How Capital Refinery works alongside quality of earnings

Capital Refinery does not perform EBITDA normalization and does not integrate with any named quality of earnings provider. Run months before a transaction window opens, it reads the same kind of evidence a quality of earnings engagement will eventually review, so the deal team sees the same conflicts earlier and with no clock running.

01

Read

Documents classified against a 41-family taxonomy, including the income statement, bank statements and the QoE add-back schedule, with figures traced to source.

02

Bridge and stress

Each add-back in the EBITDA bridge recorded as accepted, rejected or negotiated, then the result run through five house stress scenarios.

03

Grade and verify

The result graded across ten readiness axes and exported with a fingerprint and a public verification link.

Quality of earnings and Capital Refinery at a glance

DimensionQuality of earningsCapital Refinery
ScopeAdjusted EBITDA, working capital, accounting policyTen axes, including financial consistency, governance, customer concentration, key-person dependency and management responsiveness
When it runsInside a transaction window, typically post-LOICan run months or years before a transaction window
Typical cost$40K-$150K depending on size and provider$750 Self-Assessment / $4,500 Gap Review / $12,500 Institutional Readiness Assessment
Turnaround4-8 weeksNo fixed turnaround published
OutputBound report with normalized financial schedulesA graded artifact across ten axes, with named blockers and a public verification link
ReproducibilityCommission a new report from a firmRe-run the grading against new evidence
Independent verificationReputation of the issuing firmPublic verification link and a fingerprint on export
What it surfacesAdjustments to the financial statementsNamed blockers across ten axes, plus the accepted, rejected and negotiated add-back positions in the bridge

The healthiest sequence

Run the Capital Refinery readiness grading first, when the deal is months away. Surface the readiness gaps a quality of earnings engagement will not be scoped to catch, and remediate them on the deal team's own schedule. Then commission the quality of earnings report closer to the transaction window, on a business whose evidence trail is clean enough that the provider is not discovering the conflicts under deal pressure.

The two are not substitutes: Capital Refinery does not cross-check the tax return against the financials, and it does not replace the specific accounting-policy opinion a quality of earnings provider is engaged to give. It reads the schedules a deal team already has and grades what they say about readiness more broadly.

The quality of earnings report remains the standard for what it does. Capital Refinery is the read that makes its job, and the deal's outcome, more predictable.

Questions

Is Capital Refinery an alternative to a quality of earnings report?

No. A quality of earnings report validates adjusted EBITDA, working capital and accounting policy inside a transaction window. Capital Refinery reads the same kind of evidence earlier and grades readiness across ten axes. Firms typically run both at different points in the deal.

Can I use a quality of earnings report and Capital Refinery together?

Yes. Run the Capital Refinery readiness grading months before a transaction window to surface gaps early, remediate them, then commission the quality of earnings report closer to the transaction on a cleaner evidence trail.

What does a quality of earnings report not do?

It scopes mainly to adjusted EBITDA, working capital and accounting policy, runs late inside a transaction window, and produces a bound report with no independent verification mechanism beyond the issuing firm's reputation.

Does Capital Refinery cross-check figures against the tax return like some quality of earnings engagements do?

No. Cross-checking the financials against the tax return is not part of Capital Refinery's current read; it reads the financial statements, bank statements, QoE add-back schedule and the other documents it classifies on arrival.

How does Capital Refinery's cost compare to a quality of earnings engagement?

Capital Refinery is priced as a fixed fee: $750 for a Self-Assessment, $4,500 for a Readiness Gap Review, or $12,500 for a full Institutional Readiness Assessment. A middle-market quality of earnings engagement typically runs $40K to $150K depending on size and provider.

Accelerate your deal execution process.

Private markets, connected. Bring automation to your deal execution.

Founder-led access. Every working session runs on your actual documents, not a generic demo.